The increase in Web-related lawsuits is a response to the amount of money generated by software and its pervasiveness in the marketplace. Corporate attention has become focused on Web site design and its impact on revenue because Web sites have matured into a productive asset. Simultaneously, changes in the implementation of the patent law have made Web site design both more lucrative and more risky, as software and business method patents have become more acceptable to the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO).
Most recently, corporations such as Amazon.com and Ebay have incorporated patentable business methods into the design of their Web sites and brought suit against other Web sites which have incorporated these methods. Therefore, today’s Web designer must consider not just the online consumer’s wants and needs but also, the legal constraints and requirements which regulate a Web site’s appearance and functionality.
The software industry has responded to these lawsuits by calling for an end to software patents and/or business method patents. Notably, Europe has taken a less permissive attitude toward awarding software patents (Daly, 2001). Some patent owners, in particular Jeff Bezos of Amazon.com, have suggested that the USPTO be permitted to grant a software patent with a reduced term, which would better reflect the short development cycle of innovation on the Web (Cave, 2000). Congress has responded with legislation to protect early software innovators, who did not patent their software, from lawsuits by patent holders (American Inventors Protection Act, 1999.) It is now time for Web site designers, themselves, to become familiar with the issues and how they can best deal with them. A first step is to understand the type and magnitude of litigation that is ongoing. To aid in this endeavor, the cases discussed below are organized by the Web site feature at issue, in order to offer guidance to the Web designer who is contemplating implementing these particular features. Because cyber law is still in its infancy and rapidly changing, legal generalizations are difficult to make. Next, the designer should understand the importance of the Web design agreement and which clauses require special attention. Finally, the designer needs to consider the steps the designer needs to take to avoid designs which invite a lawsuit.