لطفا منتظر باشید ...
How Can You Believe in That?
My audience for this book are both the Muslim and non-Muslim. The
non-Muslim are likely to come across this book because of a desire to know more
about Islam. From what I have written thus far, they may have learned a little
about the life and path of a convert. However, they are probably seeking more
than this. Islam contains many things that are controversial in the Western
world and sometimes even within the Muslim community.These things affect how Islam and Muslims are perceived by non-Muslims
and, with the pervasion of Western ideas throughout the world, cause doubts to
creep into the minds of some Muslims. Converts have to address these things
early in their new life because they find them troubling and in need of
explanation. I have accepted Islam as God's truth, so when I find something in Islam
that seems oppressive, I have a problem. I know that God is not oppressive, so
either I have an incorrect understanding of that thing and it is not truly
oppressive, or else it is oppressive but it is not truly part of Islam. Now it
is my job to determine which of those two possibilities is the case, with an
open mind, reflection and study from numerous sources. I stress the need for
numerous sources, and I also stress finding original sources. If you want to
know about what Muslims believe, ask Muslims. This is not the work of a religious scholar and what follows is not
intended to be used as if it were. In the spirit of the title of this book,
these are merely my reflections on these issues, presented so that the reader
may understand how a Muslim convert has dealt with and come to understand some
of the more controversial aspects of Islam. These are presented in no
particular order and you may of course feel free to skip over any that are not
of interest to you. If you find that you do not agree with what I have written
on any topic, I hope it will not deter you from enjoying and benefiting from
the rest of the book.
Marriage
Women
in Marriage
Being a woman, as I thought of converting to Islam, I was greatlyconcerned about the status of woman in Islam. Especially after I converted, my
ears were full with people telling me what a horrible mistake I had made and
how I had relegated myself to a life of oppression. I had in my mind an image
of what a Muslim woman was supposed to be like and I tried to make myself fit
that role. I thought the Muslim woman was supposed to be submissive, quiet,
unopinionated, and filling her time cooking and cleaning. I tried to be that
way for awhile but it just wasn't me and I was very unhappy.In time, I realized that no one was demanding this behavior of me
except myself. As I gained exposure to other Muslim women, it dawned on me that
I had it all wrong. I was trying to be the Western stereotype of a Muslim
woman, but the stereotype was wrong.Muslim men and women observe modest behavior in each other's presence
so that generally neither of them are loud and boisterous in public. But, in
private, Muslim women are comfortably themselves. They have their opinions and
they share them with their husbands and families, who in turn listen and
respect what is said. A Muslim husband takes counsel with his wife. They work
together to complete the household work. It is true that a Muslim woman defers
to her husband when they cannot agree, but only if doing so does not cause her
to violate her religion or rights. The Qur'an is very clear that the marriage
relationship is not supposed to be one of fear or abuse, but one of comfort and
love:"And among His signs is that He created spouses from among yourselves
so that you may live in tranquility with them; And He has created love and
mercy between you." (30:21) This is a vision of the Islamic ideal, and in reality the Muslim family
is much closer to this than to the stereotypical view of a wife-beating man and
a woman who has no say in what happens in her life. Sadly, abusive and
overbearing husbands exist among the Muslims just as they do among the
Christians, Jews and everyone else. And, just as the abusive men of other
faiths, they often believe they are religiously in the right. I feel that in
this century the abused Muslim woman is at a disadvantage in comparison to her
Christian counterpart living in the West. In the past, any woman had little
practical recourse from abuse. In this century, Western women increasingly have
opportunities for help and escape without being ostracized. But the Muslim
woman is likely to live in a world where it is still taboo for people to become
involved in the family affairs of others in order to help the abused woman. The
abused Muslim woman who leaves becomes the subject of gossip and judgment while
the man often has a much easier time in maintaining his dignity and even in
remarrying. Despite this problem, I can say through comparison of every married
Muslim and non-Muslim couple I have ever met that the Muslim marriages tend to
be happier, more equal, and longer lasting. Since many Muslim marriages are
arranged without the couple knowing each other too well before marriage, they
both enter the marriage with a spirit of compromise. There does not exist the
delusion of the one right man or right woman in the world. Rather, Muslims
believe they can be compatible and have a successful loving marriage with a
variety of different types of people. All marriages take work. In my mind, one of the great failings of the
typical Western non-Muslim marriage is that it is expected to be easy. When
difficulties arise, the couple decides they must have not really found their
one right mate, and so they part; and very rarely is the parting kind and
equitable.
Finding a
Mate
Muslim youth in the West today are enticed by the romantic images onTV. They wonder where the room is for romance in an arranged marriage. Having
experienced a small bit of dating life as a non-Muslim, and then having married
a Muslim, I feel I can offer perspective. Dating is not romantic, it is not
fun, and it does not help in later married life. There is such great peer
pressure to date that it occurs among the very young, and people only get hurt.
A relationship begins, the youth may do things they regret, and a short time
later they leave each other. Then, they talk about each other, spreading gossip
and damaging each other's reputations. Most of the time the relationship is
largely physical and even basic friendship is missing between the two, although
they can't see that through the veil of their strong physical desires. This is
true even for those who try to remain chaste. As people get older,
relationships last a little longer, but the problems don't change all that
much. Finally, the "training" is over and a couple gets married. They feel
they have prepared themselves to know what kind of person is good for them
through years of dating. However, they find that in marriage, their spouse is
not the same person as he/she was while dating. And they find that both they
and their spouses have jealousy over those previous dating relationships. The
romance and true love that these people are looking for does not come
automatically like on TV. True romance comes from the commitment of the people
involved and from friendship and not from magic instant sparks. They've been
spending years looking for the ideal mate when in truth any couple who both
approach a marriage with the right state of mind and have some basic compatible
qualities can be ideal for each other. Romance comes through friendship and
compromise and accepting the other person with their faults included, and does
not come from pre-marital sex, discarding partners for others, and expecting a
near-perfect match. Dating actually diminishes romance because it desensitizes
the couple to the special-ness of the husband-wife relationship. The effort
spent on dating should be spent on developing yourself as the ideal Islamic
spouse. You will find with patience that there are others out there doing the
same as you and God willing one of them may become your life mate.Dating, or visiting each other without escort, is not the solution.
But, it is not unreasonable for someone to want to know his/her potential
spouse before agreeing to marriage. Often the characteristics that a parent
looks for in a potential spouse for their son or daughter do not match with the
characteristics that are most important to the child. The child certainly knows
something about what he or she wants and that needs to be respected. Likewise,
the wisdom of the parent due to life experience is of value and should also be
considered. Especially in the West, where Muslim communities are often small and
far from one another, it is unreasonable to expect the search for a spouse who
possesses those certain characteristics that you require to be an easy or quick
search. This is a life-decision being made, so it should be done with effort.
Muslim communities have a duty to their children to open their minds and invest
their time and money in developing any method of finding suitable spouses that
does not violate Islamic principles. In turn, the youth have a responsibility
invest their own time and effort into the process and to avoid any method that
involves violation of Islamic guidelines. After all, if you want a happy and
successful marriage, you must pursue it in a manner that is pleasing to Allah.I cannot leave the topic of marriage without addressing the two most
controversial topics: polygamy and temporary marriage. Polygamy as used here
refers specifically to polygyny, that is, the act of a man having more than one
wife, and temporary marriage is the act of taking a spouse for a fixed, finite
term rather than "until death do you part."
Polygamy
Islam makes allowance for a man to have up to four wives at a time.This is an appalling concept for many people today. The Western world holds
fast to the idea that for each man there is one ideal woman and for each woman there
is one ideal man. And, it comes natural for one raised in the West to view a
polygamous relationship as an uneven one in which the women are treated
unfairly.Other cultures have very different views that might be worth noting
here. In many cultures, in particular those stemming from Africa, a polygamous
marriage is something greatly desired. Having more than one wife for a given
man provides security to the women because the man, already having a spouse,
has demonstrated his ability to be a good husband. Further, the women enjoy
each other's companionship and help in child-rearing and other duties. In many
war-torn societies, the women greatly outnumber the men and those who desire
companionship and help in life turn to polygamous relationships because the
only other choices are to remain alone or commit sin.The polygamous relationship meets a need that could not be met
otherwise. If it were regarded with less taboo it could satisfactorily meet the
needs of many people who now do not even consider it. In practice, it is not exceedingly common for a Muslim man to have more
than one wife. That is because doing so is not about his pleasure but is rather
about responsibility to society. One verse in Qur'an which attests to this is
as follows:"And if ye fear that ye will not deal fairly by the orphans, marry of
the women who seem good to you, two or three or four; and if ye fear that ye
cannot do justice to so many then one only. Thus it is more likely that ye
will not do injustice." (4.3)Polygamy is presented as a means of serving the needs of orphans in
this verse, not as a means of serving the needs of lustful men. The Qur'an
emphasizes the need for justness in any marriage. This is a heavier burden for
a man with more than one wife because he is required to meet the needs of each
and treat them fairly. Each is entitled to her own home according to his means,
and each is entitled to equitable possessions and time. It is not permitted
that a man should ignore or neglect one wife and prefer another in treatment.It is good to keep in mind that a Muslim woman has the right to full
choice in her spouse and if she marries a man who is already married then she
does it knowingly and of her own volition. If ever the case is otherwise and
the woman is coerced into marriage, that marriage is void according to Islam
and she has no responsibility to persist in it. The one who does not have as
much choice is the first wife, for she may not be able to prohibit her husband
from taking another spouse. However, she can put into her marriage contract
that if he takes another spouse she is entitled to divorce. Many women are
discouraged from putting the clause in their contract because it might imply
that the girl does not trust her future husband. But, if a young lady knows
full well that she could not be happy in a polygamous relationship than she
should see to it that such a clause appears in her contract, no matter how
unlikely she considers that it would be needed.It takes an exceptional man and woman to build a truly Islamic, happy,
successful marriage and that is only compounded in the case of a polygamous
marriage. There is no room in the heart of a Muslim woman in a successful
polygamous relationship for jealousy. Her time with her husband is shared with
other women, but if she has a good husband she has nothing to fear because he
observes all his duties to her, and is kind and loving. In turn, she does and
is the same for him. Many people are well served by such a relationship and it
should not be looked on with such distaste. Our distaste stems from Western,
rather than Islamic, views, and also from fear of oppression. However, a
polygamous marriage is not in itself oppressive any more than a monogamous one.
Injustice within a marriage can be oppressive, and it is indeed not a
simple matter for a polygamous man to be just to multiple wives, and that is
why the Qur'an advises that the man who cannot do it justly simply should not
do it. I tried to imagine if I myself could exist happily and successfully in
a polygamous relationship. I think I could if I had confidence in my spouse. If
a man has an inclination toward taking another wife it is wrong to assume a bad
motive. Not only in this case but in any case, a woman must not assume bad
intention on the part of her husband but instead should assume good intentions
unless there is proof otherwise (and the husband should do likewise for her). The question may be asked, though, why cannot the woman take more than
one husband? At first glance, it may seem unfair that it is not permitted. But,
in light of what has been explained above, that taking more than one spouse is
not about pleasure but is a matter of meeting social needs and taking on
enormous responsibility, that question loses considerable force. Further, if a
woman has more than one husband, paternity becomes an issue, as does family
authority. The most wealthy and sophisticated societies now have the technology
to scientifically determine paternity, but this is not available to everyone.
And while successful marriages all over the world tend to involve cooperation
and counsel between husband and wife, it is also natural nearly everywhere that
ultimately the husband is the final authority in the household. When there is
more than one husband, there is no longer a natural or clear household leader
and discord results. And if there is more than one husband, inheritance becomes
an issue as well because virtually all societies determine inheritance based on
paternity.More importantly, one must ask, what societal needs would be served in
a woman having multiple husbands? While the opposite case can be seen to meet
real societal needs, it is difficult to come up with a genuine need for
polyandry (marriage of a woman with multiple men.)
Temporary
Marriage
My last topic in marriage is perhaps the most controversial within theMuslim community, and this is the temporary marriage. Among the Muslims are
some who believe that the temporary marriage is unlawful and others who believe
that it is lawful and even very important. Those who believe it is unlawful believe that the Prophet of Islam
(saw), through God's command, allowed it for a very short period and then
disallowed it. Those who believe it is lawful believe that the Prophet of Islam
(saw) never disallowed it but rather it was a Caliph, after the death of the
Prophet (saw) at which time Islam cannot be changed, who made it illegal. Further, those who find it lawful turn to a verse in the Qur'an in
which they believe it (temporary marriage) is mentioned. They say that
something which is lawful in Qur'an and not made unlawful somewhere else in the
Qur'an must be permissible. The matter of dispute is in 4:24, here presented as
in the Puya/Ali translation and tafsir (explanatory notes) of the Holy
Qur'an:"As to those whom you married for a fixed time (Mut'a), give
them their agreed dowries; and there is no sin for you in what you mutually
agree together after what has been settled." The corresponding explanatory note follows:"Famastamta-tum bihi [the Arabic in the text which refers to the
marriage] provides for a temporary marriage, knows as Mut'a. It has been
specifically made lawful by the Qur'an and the Holy Prophet, therefore this
provision subsists as unrescinded.One day, for no reason at all, and having no authority to amend a law
given and practiced by the Holy Prophet, the second caliph declared from the
pulpit:'Two Mut'as (temporary marriage and combining hajj with umra)
were in force during the time of the Holy Prophet, but now I decree both of
them as unlawful; and I will punish those who practice them.' (Tafsir Kabir,
Durr al Manthur, Kashshaf, Mustadrak and others).According to Tirmidhi even his [the second caliph's] son, Ibne Umar,
refused to agree with his father's action because it was made lawful by Allah
and His Prophet, whose pronouncements could never be revoked by anyone after
him.Therefore the Shia school of thought holds both Mut'as lawful.
Ali ibn abi Talib reversed the uncalled-for innovation of the second caliph,
and thereafter it was never again prohibited."Now if we look at a different translation, we find that there is no
clear mention of the marriage referred to as being temporary in nature:"And those of whom ye seek content (by marrying them), give unto them
their portions as a duty. And there is no sin for you in what you do by mutual
agreement after the duty (hath been done)." (Pickthall) Thus, for one who is not an expert in Qur'anic Arabic, it is difficult
to determine whether "famastamta-tum bihi" refers to a temporary
marriage. It may be easier, then, to adhere by the law according to the Islamic
school that you choose to follow, but this is not a truly satisfactory answer
for the convert who may have not yet chosen a school. However, it is possible
to study the works of those who are more knowledgeable in Qur'anic Arabic or
you can try to determine the matter using the information on which nearly all
Muslims agree.That on which nearly all Muslims agree, both Sunni and Shia, is that
the temporary marriage was made lawful by the Prophet (saw) of Islam and was
not made unlawful until after Allah (swt) had completed and perfected Islam and
the Prophet (saw) had died. It is also largely agreed upon that anyone after
the Prophet (saw) cannot make anything that was lawful, unlawful, or anything
that was prohibited, allowed, except on a temporary basis stemming from urgent
political need. As an example of a temporary change stemming from urgent
political need, it would be acceptable for an Islamic scholar to prohibit the
use of birth control temporarily to counteract an oppressor's rule that all
Muslims must not procreate. Normally, many methods of birth control are
permissible for Muslims, but in an emergency when the future of the Muslim society
is at stake, the scholar can rule that they should not use birth control until
the situation is alleviated.Therefore it would seem that the second caliph's ruling cannot have any
effect on the permissibility of temporary marriage today and as such the conclusion
I make is that it is permissible. There are a minority of Sunnis who turn to
different traditions that indicate that the Prophet (saw) himself forbade Mut'a,
but those traditions contradict each other and do not stand up to close
scrutiny and we are left with the same conclusion that temporary marriage is
permitted. But, to address that opinion, the following is quoted from the Shia
Encyclopedia (available online):"Sabra al-Juhanni reported on the authority of his father that while he
was with Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him), he said: O' people, I
had permitted you to contract temporary marriage with women, but Allah has
forbidden it (now) until the Day of Resurrection. So he who has any (woman with
this type of marriage contract) he should let her off, and do not take back
anything you have given to them (as dower). Sunni references: Sahih Muslim, English version, v2, chapter DXLI (titled: Temporary
Marriage), Tradition #3255 Sahih Muslim, Arabic version, 1980 Edition Pub. in Saudi Arabia, v2,
p1025, Tradition #21, "Kitab al-Nikah, Bab Nikah al-Mut'a" 'A side comment here is that again the word "Istimta'a" has been used
in this tradition for temporary marriage which is exactly what Quran has used.'
"In the next tradition after the above tradition in Sahih Muslim, the
same narrator (Sabra) has narrated the same tradition with addition that: "I saw Allah's Messenger standing between the pillar
and gate of Ka'ba when speaking the Hadith." Sunni references: Sahih Muslim, English version, v2, chapter DXLI (titled: Temporary
Marriage), Tradition #3256 Sahih Muslim, Arabic version, 1980 Edition Pub. in Saudi Arabia, v2,
p1025, Tradition #21, "Kitab al-Nikah, Bab Nikah al-Mut'a" "The following tradition, however, indicates that the Prophet allowed
Temporary marriage after the battle of Hunain (after 10/8 AH) which was after
the conquest of Mecca: Narrated Iyas Ibn Salama on the authority of his
father that Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) gave sanction for
contracting temporary marriage for three nights in the year of Autas (this was
after the Battle of Hunain in 8H), and then forbade it. {Note: The sentence inside parentheses is the Saudi translator's
footnote, and is not mine.} Sunni references: Sahih Muslim, English version, v2, chapter DXLI (titled: Temporary
Marriage), Tradition #3251 Sahih Muslim, Arabic version, 1980 Edition Pub. in Saudi Arabia, v2,
p1023, Tradition #18, "Kitab al-Nikah, Bab Nikah al-Mut'a" "Now, let us see what the problems are: If the Prophet has forbidden the temporary marriage FOREVER on the Day
of Khaibar (1/7 AH), why was it practiced even after the battle of Hunain
(after 10/8 AH) with the direct order of the Prophet? (See the reference above)
In other words:How is that possible that one is forbidden FOREVER and in two different
points of time, on the Day of Khaibar (1/7 AH) and on the victory Mecca (9/8
AH) FOREVER, and people were practicing it between these two instants of time
and after these two instances with the order of the Prophet?In the mentioned tradition about the battle of Hunain, it is said that
the messenger of Allah (sa) permitted Mut'a after the battle of Hunain.
So we cannot say people did it because they did not know it was forbidden
forever. The traditions confirms that Mut'a was done with the direct
order of the Prophet. So how can we justify these few alleged traditions that
the Prophet forbade it forever before that? Two Sunni scholars: al-Qurtubi (in his commentary of Quran) and
al-Nawawi (in his commentary of Sahih Muslim) are of the opinion that different
traditions concerning the ban of Mut'a specify seven different dates!!!
.What will be wrong if we take the opinion of Imam Ali (as), the most
knowledgeable one among the companions who said:"Mut'a is a mercy from Allah to his servants. If it
were not for Umar forbidding it, no one would commit (the sin) of fornication
except the wretched (Shaqi)" But why would anyone want to be in a temporary marriage? What purpose
does it serve? Temporary marriage is not intended as an alternative to
permanent marriage, but rather, is an option for those who have needs that
permanent marriage cannot meet. To claim that permanent marriage meets all
needs is foolish upon close examination of society. Imam Ali (as), the 4th
caliph of Islam according to the Sunnis and the first Imam (one appointed by
God to succeed in leadership after the Prophet (saw) and to uphold the
religion) according to the Shias, is quoted on this issue as saying,"It [temporary marriage] is permitted and absolutely
allowed for the one whom Allah has not provided with the means of permanent
marriage so that he may be chaste by performing Mut'a [temporary marriage]." Wasail, vol. 14 pp.449-450.In modern society, the temporary marriage may meet the needs of someone
who is travelling for a long time and is in need of companionship, or someone
who cannot find a permanent spouse. Additionally it may serve the needs of
someone without the financial means to have a wedding and then to support his
wife financially. (The requirement that he maintain his spouse according to his
means and according to what she is accustomed to do not have to apply in
temporary marriage.) The elderly widows who have little realistic chance of
finding another permanent spouse can more easily find temporary spouses to
serve the need of companionship. Similarly, youth who are too young for the
responsibilities of permanent marriage but in danger of committing sin may
lawfully meet in a Mut'a marriage. This last case does not give freedom
for youth to freely mingle with the opposite sex and have intercourse. A
condition mitigating against this abuse is the requirement that a virgin female
have permission of her father to enter any marriage relationship, including Mut'a,
unless the father is found to be one who is unreasonable in that regard. It is
further commonly required that a condition of the marriage be that sex shall
not take place. Mut'a is the way to avoid sin when permanent marriage is not possible. Some
Muslims today commit sin prior to their marriage with the person that they are
engaged to. Islam is clear that, between men and women, touching, viewing parts
of each other's bodies that should be covered, and visiting while unescorted
are sins unless they are closely related or married. Engagement is not marriage, yet couples involve themselves in this
behavior that should take place only in marriage. The logical alternative to
avoid sin is simply to have a temporary marriage prior to the permanent
marriage so that the couple can make sure they are suited to each other.
