Sunni Feedback on The Issues of Infallibility and Ahulbayt [Electronic resources] نسخه متنی

Tragedy of Karbala as reported by the Sunnis (Part IX) When the head of al Husayn, peace be on him, arrived and
after
Ibn Sad arrived on the next day (bringing) with him the
daughters
and household of al-Husayn, peace be on him, Ibn Ziyad sat
before
the people in the governor's palace.
He had given
the people a general
summons and had ordered them to be present (to see) the head.

He
put it in front of him, and he began to look at it with a
smile.
In his
hand he had a cane and he began to poke at the teeth with it.

When Zayd b.
Arqam, a Companion of the Prophet who
was
(then) an old man, saw him poking at the teeth with the cane,
he said
Take your
cane away from those two lips.

For, by God,
other than
Whom there is no deity, I have seen the lips
of the
Apostle of God, may God bless him and his family,
touch those
two lips countless times.
(With that) he began to weep.

Does God make your eyes weep? asked Ibn Ziyad.
Or
are you
weeping because of God's victory? If it was not for the fact
that you
are an old man who has become silly and your mind has left
you, I
would cut off your head.
Zayd b.
Arqam stood up in front of him and went to
his house.

(Meanwhile) the family of al-Husayn, peace be on him, was
brought
before Ibn Ziyad.
Zaynab, the sister of al-Husayn,
peace be on him,
came in in the middle of the group, pretending not to be
herself; she
was wearing her dirtiest clothes.
She went and sat
in a corner of the
palace and her maids crowded around her.

Who is that woman who has gone to the side and has sat
in a
corner with her women? Ibn Ziyad demanded but Zaynab
did not
answer.
He repeated the question about her a second
time.
This is
Zaynab, daughter of Fatima, the daugher of the
Apostle of
God, may God bless him and grant him peace,
one of her women told him.

Praise be to God Who has disgraced you, killed you and
revealed
the false nature of your claims, said Ibn Ziyad as he
came towards
her.
Praise be to
God Who has favoured us with His Prophet,
Muhammad,
may God bless him and his family, answered
Zaynab, and
He has purified us completely from sin.
He
only
disgraces the great sinner and reveals the false
nature of
the profligate.

Such men are not among us,
praise be to
God.

How do you consider God has treated your House?
asked Ibn Ziyad,
God decreed
death for them and they went forward (bravely)
to their
resting-places, Zaynab replied, God will gather
you and us
together.
You will plead your excuses to Him and
we will be
your adversaries before Him.
Ibn Ziyad became enraged and burnt with anger.

Governor, intervened 'Amr b.
Hurayth,
She is only a woman
and women are not responsible for anything that they say.
Do
not
blame her mistakes.
God has healed my soul from your tyranny and the
rebellion of
your House, he said to her.

Zaynab, peace be on her, became weak and wept.
By my life,
she cried out to him, You have killed the
mature ones
(of my family); you have pierced my family;
you have cut
down my young branches; and you have pulled
out my root.
If
this heals you, then you have been healed.
By my life, declared Ibn Ziyad, this is a
woman who makes
poetry.

Your father was a poet.
What has a
woman to do with poetry?, she answered.
Indeed
I have
(things) to distract me from poetry but my heart
causes me
say what I am saying.
Ali b.
al-Husayn, peace be on them, was presented
to him.
Who are you? he asked.

I am Ali b.
al-Husayn he answered.
Didn't God kill 'Ali b.
al-Husayn?
I have a brother who is also called Ali, answered
'Ali, peace be
on him, the people killed him.
Rather God killed him, affirmed Ibn Ziyad.
God receives the souls at the time of their death [
XXXIX : 42].

How dare you answer me like that! shouted Ibn
Ziyad angrily,
and that will be the last of you because of (your)
answer to me.
Take
him away and cut his head off!
Zaynab, his aunt, clung on to him, pleading: O Ibn
Ziyad, haven't
you had enough of our blood?
Then she clung on to him and said: By God, I will not
leave him.
If
you kill him, kill me with him.

Ibn Ziyad looked at her and at him, and said, How
wonderful is
family relationship! I think she wants me to kill her with
him.
Leave
him, for I see him (now) for what he is.
He rose from his assembly to leave the palace and go to the
mosque.
He went up on the pulpit.

He
praised and glorified God,
then he said:
Praise be to
God Who has revealed the truth and the
followers of
the truth, and has given victory to the
Commander of
the faithful, Yazid, and his party, and
has killed
the liar who is the son of a liar and his
Shia.
At this 'Abd Allah b.
Afif al-Azdi, who had been
one of the
Shiaa of the Commander of the faithful (Ali b.
Abi
Talib) stood in
front of him and shouted:
O enemy of
God, you are the liar and your father and (the man)
who
appointed you and his father.

O Ibn Murjana, you
kill the
sons of
Prophets and take the place of men of truth on the pulpit.
Get him for me, ordered Ibn Ziyad.
The soldiers seized him but he gave the battle cry of al-Azd.
Seven
hundred of them (quickly) gathered and took him away from the
soldiers.
At night Ibn Ziyad sent someone to get him out of his house.

He
was executed and crucified in al-Sabkha, may God have mercy
on him.
The (next) morning Ubayd Allah b.
Ziyad sent the
head of al-
Husayn, peace be on him, (to Yazid) after it had been taken
through
all the streets and tribes of Kufa.

[It is reported from Zayd b.
Arqam:] It was
brought past; it was stuck on a spear and I was
in a room in
my (house).
As it was opposite me I heard
it recite:
Or do you think that the Companions of the
Cave and the
inscription were among Our wonderful signs.
[ XVIII, 9
].

My flesh shuddered and I called out,
O son of the
Apostle of God, your head is miraculous,
miraculous.

[ This account is not in Tabari ] When they had finished taking it around Kufa and had brought
it
back to the palace door, Ibn Ziyad gave it to Zahar b.
Qays
and he
(also) gave him the heads of his companions.
He
despatched him to
Yazid b.
Muawiya and he sent with him Abu Burda b.
'Awf
al-Azdi,
and Tariq b.
Abi Zubyan al-Azdi together with a
group of Kufans, to
take them to Yazid b.
Mu'awiya in Damascus.

[ Abd Allah b.
Rabiaa al-Himyari reported: ] I was with Yazid b.
MuCawiya in Damascus when Zahar
b.
Qays
brought the head to him.
Woe upon you! What is behind you? What have you
got?
demanded Yazid.
O Commander
of the faithful, he replied, I bring good
news of
God's victory and support.

Al-Husayn b.
Ali,
peace be on
them, came against us with eighteen men
of his House
and sixty of his Shi'a.
We went out to
meet them
and we asked them to surrender and submit
to the
authority of the governor, 'Ubayd Allah b.
Ziyad,
or to fight.

They
chose to fight rather than to surrender.
We attacked
them as the sun rose and surrounded them on
every side.
Eventually
(our) swords took their toll of
the heads of
the people and they began to flee without
having any
refuge (to go to).
They (tried to) take refuge
from us on
the (open) hills and in the hollows, like the
doves seek
refuge from a hawk.

By God,
Commander of the faithful, it was nothing but the
slaughtering
of animals for slaughter.
(It was only the time
taken by)
the sleep of a man taking his siesta (before) we
had come
upon the last of them.
There were their naked
bodies,
their
blood-stained clothes, their faces thrown in the dust.
The sun
burst down on them; the wind scattered (dust) over
them; their
visitors were (scavenging) eagles and vultures.

Yazid looked down for a time, then he raised his head and
said:
I would have
been satisfied with your obedience (to my
orders)
without this killing of al-Husayn, peace be on
him.
If
it had been me who had accompanied him, I would
have let him
off (such a fate).
After Ubayd Allah b.
Ziyad had despatched the head
of al-
Husayn, he ordered the women and the young boys to be made
ready
for travelling.

He ordered Ali b.
al-Husayn,
peace be on them, to be
chained with a chain around his neck.

Then he
despatched them, to
follow the heads, with Muhaffir b.
Thalaba al Aidhi
and Shamir b.
Dhi al-Jawshan.
They set out with them until they
caught up with the
people with the head.

Ali b.
al-Husayn
did not speak a word to any of
the people who had the head on that journey.
Eventually
they reached
(their destination).

When they reached the door of
Yazid's (palace),
Muhaffir b.
Tha'laba raised his voice and shouted:
Here is Muhaffir
b.
Thalaba who has brought the Commander of the
faithful these vile
profligates.

Ali b.
al-Husayn, peace be on him, answered him:
What did the
mother of Muhaffir give birth to more evil and
more
grievous (than him)?
When the heads were put in front of Yazid and among them was
the
head of al-Husayn, peace be on him, Yazid recited:
We will
split the skull of proud men (who come) against us;
they were
very disobedient and oppressive.
Yahya b.
al-Hakam, the brother of Marwan b.
al-Hakam
recited:

On the bank
(of the river) a great army met him who is
closer in
kinship (to Yazid) than Ibn Ziyad (is), the man
with a false
lineage.
The offspring of Sumayya has acquired status, while the
offspring of the daughter of the Apostle of God is (given)
none.
Yazid struck his hand against the chest of Yahya b.
al-Hakam
and
shouted, Be quiet!
Then he said to Ali b.
al-Husayn, peace be on them
Son of al
Husayn, your father cut (the bond of) kinship with
me and
showed ignorance of my rights, trying to deprive me of
my position
of authority.

(Now) God has treated him in the way
you have
seen.
No
misfortune strikes the earth nor yourselves unless
it has been
written in a book before we bring it into
existence;
that is easy for God [ LVII : 22 ]
replied 'Ali b.
al-Husayn.

Answer him, Yazid urged his son, Khalid.
However
Khalid did
not know what to say in reply.
So Yazid answered:
Say rather: Whatever misfortune has struck you is because
of what your hands have earned.

And (God)
forgives much
[ XLII : 30 ] He summoned the women and the children and they were made to
sit in front of him.

What he saw was dreadful.
May God detest Ibn Murjana, he said: If
there had been (any
bond of) kinship between him and you, he would not have done
this
to you; he would not have sent you in this state.

[Fatima, daughter of al-Husayn, peace be on him, reported:] When we sat before Yazid, he showed pity on us.
An
Ahmar of the Syrians
stood up and said to Yazid: Commander of the faithful,
give me this one.
He meant me.
(Then) I was a pretty young girl.

I
shuddered for I
thought that that would be allowed to them.
I
caught hold of the skirt
of my aunt Zaynab and she told (me) that that would not
happen.
She
said to the Syrian:
By God, you
are a liar.
By God, you are (too) lowly born! Such
a thing is
not for you nor for him (to decide).

You are a liar, Yazid cried out angrily.
That
is for me (to
decide).

If I wish to do anything, I can do it.
No, by God,
she replied, God would only let you do that
if you left
our faith and professed belief in another
(religion).
It is me, screamed Yazid, distraught with anger,
whom you are
treating in this (way).

It is your father who has
left the religion, and
your brother
I am led by
the religion of God, the religion of my father
and the
religion of my brother, she answered, and (it is what)
you are led
by, and your grandfather and your father, if you
are a
Muslim.
Enemy of God, you lie, he shouted.
You are a
Commander of the faithful, (yet) you vilify
unjustly and
you have become oppressive with your authority,
she
answered.
(At this) he was ashamed and became silent.

Give me
that girl,
repeated the Syrian.
Be a bachelor,
Yazid said to him, May
God strike you dead!
Then he ordered the women to be lodged in a house on (the)
banks
(of the river).

With them (also he sent) their
brother, 'Ali b.
al-
Husayn, peace be on them.
(Later) a house was set
aside for them,
which was attached to Yazid's own house.

They
resided (there) for
several days, (After a short time) he summoned al-Nu'man b.
Bashir
and told him to make preparations to take these women back to
Medina.
When he was aoubt to despatch them, he
summoned
Ali b.
al-Husayn, peace be on them.

He
took him aside.
God curse Ibn Murjana, he said.
If
I had been with your father,
he would never have asked me for a favour without me granting
him
it; I would have protected him from death with all my power.
But
God has decreed what you have seen.

Write to me
from Medina and
everything that you need will be yours.

He presented clothes to him and to his family.
He
sent with them in
the group (of men under the command) of Numan b.
Bashir,
a
messenger, who brought him (al-Numan) the order to set out
with
them in the night; and that they should go in front of him
but they
should never be out of his sight.
When they
stopped, he should go
aside from them and he and his followers should separate
around
them like a group of guards over them.

He should
(only) keep away
from them when any person of their group wanted to wash or
perform a need, so he (or she) would not be ashamed.

(The messenger) set off with them amid the group of al-Numan.
(Al-Nu'man) continued to stay close to them along the road
but he
was kind to them as Yazid had instructed him and he looked
after
them until they entered Medina.

After Ibn Ziyad had despatched the head of al-Husayn, peace
be on
him, to Yazid, he went to Abd al-Malik b Abi al-Harith
al-Sulami
and told him,
Go to 'Amr
b.
Sad b.
al-As in Medina and give him
the good
news of the killing of al-Husayn (peace be
on him).

[ Abd al-Malik reported: ] I rode my mount and went towards Medina.
(On the
way) one of
Quraysh met me.

What is the news? he asked.
The news is for the governor, (then) you will hear
it, I answered.
We belong to God and to Him we will return, he
said.
By God,
al-Husayn, peace be on him, has been killed.
When I went to Amr b.
Said, he asked: What is
your purpose?
What will please the governor, I answered,
Al-Husayn, peace
be on him, has been killed.

Go out and announce his being killed, he told me.
I announced (it).
I have never heard such wailing
as the wailing of
the Banu Hashim in their houses for al-Husayn b.
Ali,
peace be on
him, when they heard the announcement of his death.
I
went back (in)
to 'Amr b.
Said.

When he saw me, he
smiled at me and laughed.
Then
he quoted a verse of Amr b.
Madikarib:
Then women
of Banu Ziyad raised a great lament like
the
lamentation of our women mourning (after the battle)
of al-Arnab.
This lamentation is in return for the lamentation for
Uthman,
'Amr exclaimed.
Then he went up on the pulpit and
informed the
people about the killing of al-Husayn b.
Ali, and
he summoned
(them to obey) Yazid b.
Muawiya.

(After
that) he went down.
One of the retainers (mawali) of Abd Allah b.
Jafar
b.
Abi Talib,
peace be on him, went to him and announced the news of the
killing of
his two sons and he said that we (all return) to God.
This is what we have through al-Husayn b.
Ali,
peace be on
them, said Abu Salasil, the retainer (mawl؛) of Abd
Allah.
O son of an
obscene (woman), exclaimed Abd Allah b.
Jafar,
taking off his shoe (to strike him).
Are you
saying this
of al- ,Husayn, peace be on him? If I had
been present
with him, I would have preferred not to
leave him
and to be killed with him.

By God, I would not
have
withheld those two from him and I take consolation
fromwhat
befell them in that these two were struck down
with my
brother and cousin, consoling him and enduring
with him.

He went forward to those who were sitting with him and said:
Praise be to
God, Who has (made life hard for me) through
the death of
al-Husayn.
For I did not console al-Husayn
with my own
hands, my two sons consoled him.
Umm Luqman, the daughter of Aqil b.
Abi Talib, may
God have
mercy on them, came out crying when she heard the news of the
death
of al-Husayn, peace be on him.

With her were her
sisters Umm Hani',
Ramla and Zaynab, daughters of Aqil b.
Abi Talib,
may God have
mercy on them.

She wept for her (relatives) slain
on the bank and
she recited:
What would
you say if the Prophet asked you: What have
you, the
last of the (religious) communities, done
With my
offspring and my family after my departure from
them? They
are prisoners and slain and have been stained
with their
own blood.
What sort of
reward is this for my advice to you, that
you should
oppose me by doing evil to my blood relations?

On the night of the day upon which Amr b.
Said had
given the public
notice of the killing of al Husayn b.
Ali, peace be
upon them, in
Mecona, in the middle of the night the Medians heard a voice
calling
out.

They listened to the voice but they did not
see any person.
The voice called out:
O men who
ignorantly killed al Husayn; hear the news of
punishment
and chastisement
All the
people of heaven, prophets, angels and slain,
prosecute
you.
You have
been cursed by the tongue of the son of David,
and (that)
of Moses and (that) of the master of the
Gospels.

End of Part IX End of this Series References:
The History of al Tabari Volume XIX The Caliphate
of Yazid b.
Muawiyah Translated by I.
K.
A
Howard Paper back - ISBN
0-7914-0041-7 Extra quotes are from:
Kitab al Irshad Shaykh al Mufid Translated by I.
K.
A
Howard Tahrike Tarsile Quran Paper back - ISBN
0-940368-11-0